Susan Reeves Century 21 Community Logo

5201 BUTTER CUP DR, COLUMBIA, MO 65203 (MLS# 429080)

5201 BUTTER CUP DR, COLUMBIA, MO 65203

$839,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 5 Baths: 3 Square Footage: 3,121 Status: Active
Current Price: $839,000 List Date: 8/08/2025 Last Modified: 1/14/2026

Description

This stunning new construction ranch home offers exceptional convenience and space with a unique 4-car garage setup, featuring a 3-car attached garage and an additional built-in deep garage accessed via a separate driveway. Upon arrival, you'll be welcomed by the striking double door entry, setting the tone for the stylish and thoughtfully designed interior. Step inside and discover an open-concept layout that seamlessly connects 5 spacious bedrooms and 3 beautifully finished bathrooms, perfect for modern living. Buyer to verify all facts and information including but not limited to schools, taxes, sq. footage, lot size, room size, restrictions, HOA fees, etc.

Supplements: The center of the home is the gourmet kitchen, where gleaming quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a large center island invite culinary creativity and social gatherings. The connected dining room overlooks a lovely screened porch, offering peaceful views and a relaxing retreat for outdoor moments. Stunning built-ins and a fireplace provide charm and comfort, while the finished basement is a true standout, featuring a full-size wet bar ideal for entertaining. Every detail of this home exudes quality and luxury, making it the perfect place to call your own.

More Information MLS# 429080

General Property Description

Attached/Detached: Detached # of Baths-Half: 0 Primary Style: Ranch Garage Capacity: 4 Sq Ft Source: Listing Agent Age Description: Under Construction ExpDate/Complete(NC): 2025-10-07 Lot Dimensions: 91.97x135.22x117.57x167 Appx Fin Sq Ft Main #: 1836 Appx Fin Sq Ft Lower #: 1285 Appx Fin Sq Ft Upper #: 0 Appx Fin Other Sq Ft #: 0 Basement: Yes Appx UnFin Sq Ft Main #: 0 Appx UnFin Sq Ft Lower #: 551 Appx UnFin Sq Ft Upper #: 0 Appx UnFin Other Sq Ft #: 0 Appx UnFin Sq Ft Total #: 511 Builder Name: J. Jones House Faces: E Type: Single Family Residence # of Bedrooms: 5 Baths Full: 3 Total Bathrooms: 3 Appx Fin Sq Ft Total #: 3121 Year Built: 2025

Location Tax & Legal

Cross Street: Cromford Mill Dr. Zoning: Single Family Res School District: Columbia Elementary Sch: Mill Creek Middle/Jr High Sch: John Warner Senior Sch: Rock Bridge HOA/Condo: Yes HOA/Condo $: 500 HOA/Condo Descrip: Annual HOA/Condo Init: Yes HOA/Condo Init $: 1000 Other Fees: NO Condo Ext Maint: None Legal Description: Legacy Farms Plat No. 1 Lot 1064 Auction: No Land Lease: No Land Lease Descrip: N/A Located within City of Columbia: Yes

Remarks & Misc

Directions: Nifong to South on Sinclair to right on Crabapple to right on Butter Cup.

Status Change Info

List Price/Sqft: 268.82 Status: Active Status Change Date: 2025-08-08

Licensee Per/Int Dis

Lic is princ and/or dir. or ind, owner int. in Sel: 1 Licensee is Seller: 1

Rooms

Bedroom 2: 1 Bedroom 2 Level: Main Bedroom 3: 1 Bedroom 3 Level: Main Bedroom 4: 1 Bedroom 4 Level: Lower Bedroom 5: 1 Bedroom 5 Level: Lower Dining Room: 1 Dining Room Level: Main Family Room: 1 Family Room Level: Lower Foyer: 1 Foyer Level: Main Full Bathroom: 1 Full Bathroom Level: Main Kitchen: 1 Kitchen Level: Main Living Room: 1 Living Room Level: Main Master Bedroom: 1 Master Bedroom Level: Main Other: 1 Other Level: Main

Property Disclosure

Property Disclosure To Be Provided: No

Foundation Type

Full Bsmt Part Fin: 1 Walkout Basement: 1

Crops

None: 1

Appliances

Dishwasher: 1 Disposal: 1 Gas Range: 1 Exhaust Fan: 1

Interior/Features

Bar-Wet Bar: 1 Ceiling/PaddleFan(s): 1 Garage Dr Opener(s): 1 High Spd Int Access: 1 Laundry-Main Floor: 1 Main Lvl Master Bdrm: 1 Smoke Detector(s): 1 Split Bedroom Design: 1 Stand AloneShwr/MBR: 1 Tub-Garden: 1 Tub/Shower: 1 Walk in Closet(s): 1 Washer/DryerConnectn: 1

Cooling

Central Electric: 1

Exterior Finish

Concrete Board/Fiber Cement: 1 Stone Veneer: 1

Road Responsibility

Public Maintained Road: 1

Road Surface Type

Paved: 1

Other Structures

None: 1

Foundation Access

Garage: 1 Walkout: 1

Possession

At Closing: 1

Heating

Forced Air: 1 Natural Gas: 1

Foundation Material

Poured Concrete: 1

Restriction/Easement

Easements/RightofWay: 1 Recorded Plat: 1 Subdiv Restrictions: 1 Zoning Regulations Apply: 1

Arch./Style

Traditional: 1

Deck

Back: 1 Screened: 1

Dining

Kit/Din Combo: 1

Topo/Lot Description

Level: 1 Rolling: 1

Exterior Features

Full Sprinklers: 1 Clubhouse-Community: 1 Driveway-Paved: 1 Pool-Community: 1 Windows-Vinyl: 1

Roof

ArchitecturalShingle: 1

Utilities

Electric-Boone County Electric: 1 Gas-Natural: 1 Sewage-City: 1 Trash-City: 1 Water-City: 1

Fireplace

In Living Room: 1

Zoning

R-1 One- Family Dwelling*: 1

Flooring

Carpet: 1 Tile: 1 Vinyl: 1

Kitchen/Features

Cabinets-Wood: 1 Counter-SolidSurface: 1 Island: 1 Pantry: 1

Patio

Back: 1 Concrete: 1

Porch

Covered: 1 Front: 1

Baths Full-3/4

Lower Level: 1 Main Level: 2 Total: 3

Baths-Half

Total: 0

Contract Information

Current Price: $839,000 List Date: 2025-08-08 List Price: $839,000

Location, Tax & Legal

Area: Southwest Street No #: 5201 Street: BUTTER CUP Street Suffix: DR County: Boone State/Province: MO Zip Code: 65203 Subdivision: LEGACY FARMS Mapping ID #: 2020000200260001

Property Features

Road Responsibility: Public Maintained Road Road Surface Type: Paved Foundation Type: Full Bsmt Part Fin; Walkout Basement Cooling: Central Electric Crops: None Deck: Back; Screened Dining: Kit/Din Combo Exterior Features: Clubhouse-Community; Driveway-Paved; Pool-Community; Windows-Vinyl Exterior Finish: Concrete Board/Fiber Cement; Stone Veneer Fireplace: In Living Room Flooring: Carpet; Tile; Vinyl Foundation Access: Garage; Walkout Foundation Material: Poured Concrete Heating: Natural Gas; Forced Air Appliances: Dishwasher; Disposal; Gas Range; Exhaust Fan Other Structures: None Patio: Back; Concrete Porch: Front; Covered Possession: At Closing Roof: ArchitecturalShingle Rooms: Bedroom 2; Bedroom 3; Bedroom 4; Bedroom 5; Dining Room; Family Room; Foyer; Full Bathroom; Kitchen; Living Room; Master Bedroom; Other Utilities: Electric-Boone County Electric; Gas-Natural; Sewage-City; Trash-City; Water-City Zoning: R-1 One- Family Dwelling*

Room Information

Full Bathroom Level: Main Full Bathroom Level: Main Full Bathroom Level: Lower Living Room Level: Main Length: 18.67 Length: 18.67 Width: 16.33 Width: 16.33 Kitchen Level: Main Length: 16.58 Length: 16.58 Width: 10.67 Width: 10.67 Dining Room Level: Main Length: 11.25 Length: 11.25 Width: 7.67 Width: 7.67 Other Level: Main Length: 7.08 Length: 7.08 Width: 5.33 Width: 5.33 Remarks: Drop zone Foyer Level: Main Length: 10.33 Length: 10.33 Width: 7.50 Width: 7.50 Master Bedroom Level: Main Length: 13.58 Length: 13.58 Width: 13.50 Width: 13.50 Bedroom 2 Level: Main Length: 12.25 Length: 12.25 Width: 11.25 Width: 11.25 Bedroom 3 Level: Main Length: 11.67 Length: 11.67 Width: 11.25 Width: 11.25 Family Room Level: Lower Length: 27.58 Length: 27.58 Width: 20.17 Width: 20.17 Remarks: plus 12x8 wet bar Bedroom 4 Level: Lower Length: 12.67 Length: 12.67 Width: 10.83 Width: 10.83 Bedroom 5 Level: Lower Length: 13.58 Length: 13.58 Width: 11.83 Width: 11.83
Listing Office: Bev & Co. Realty, LLC
Listing Agent: Bev Curtis
Co Listing Agent: Julia Ames
Last Updated: January - 14 - 2026
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Susan Reeves Team with Century 21 Community in Columbia MO - Seal Registered White Logo
Contact

Susan Reeves Team
CENTURY 21 COMMUNITY
111 E Broadway
Columbia, MO 65203

Our Mission

Expert Strategy for Your Big Life Moves. 

Serving Columbia, Missouri and nearby communities — including Ashland, Centralia, Hallsville, and Boonville — the Susan Reeves Team with Century 21 Community provides expert real estate strategy and trusted guidance for buyers and sellers across Mid-Missouri.

@2025 Susan Reeves PC. All rights reserved.

CENTURY 21®, the CENTURY 21 Logo and C21® are service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Century 21 Real Estate LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate.